Menu > Articles de la revue de presse : - l'ensemble [tous | francophone] - par mots clé [tous] - par site [tous] - le tagwall [voir] - Top bi-hebdo de la revue de presse [Voir]

---

S'abonner au fil RSS global de la revue de presse

---

Présentation : In a disappointing ruling, the First Circuit Court of Appeals today overturned a decision by a federal district court that had downsized damages in Sony v. Tenenbaum, a file-sharing case in which a jury originally ordered a college student to pay 675,000 for infringing copyrights in 30 songs. District court Judge Nancy Gertner had found the award so oppressive as to be unconstitutional, and reduced it to 67,500. The appellate court did not expressly disagree on the constitutional question but found the court should not have considered the issue. Citing the doctrine of constitutional avoidance, which dictates that courts should avoid tackling constitutional issues unnecessarily, the court found that Judge Gertner should first have considered using a procedure called remittitur. Under this procedure, she could have lowered the damages amount, but, if the record companies chose not to accept the new amount, they could have asked for a new trial. Working with the Stanford Fair Use Project and the Samuelson Law, Technology Public Policy Clinic, EFF had filed a brief in the case urging the First Circuit to affirm Judge Gertner's ruling, particularly in light of the intimidating effect of excessive copyright damage awards on fair users. Too often, creative people with strong and legitimate fair use defenses will fear standing up to legal threats, because the risk of losing in court is just too high. As we explained then, this case offered an important opportunity to clarify copyright law for creators and protect their due process rights. Too bad the appellate court declined to take it. Interestingly, though, the court's opinion does echo another district court in suggesting that it is time for Congress to take another look at statutory damages We comment that this case raises concerns about application of the Copyright Act that Congress may wish to examine. Hear, hear.






Les derniers articles du site "EFF.org Updates" :

- EFF Mourns the Loss of Steve Jobs
- EU Parliament Takes the First Step to Prevent Sales of Surveillance Equipment Used to Violate Human Rights
- Safeconnect, Universities, P2P, Network Security and Risk The Tangled World of Policy Enforcement on Other People's Computers
- Courts Call Out Copyright Trolls' Coercive Business Model, Threaten Sanctions
- Party Like It's 1986 - Demand Privacy Like It's 2011
- Human Rights and Digital Freedom Groups Call for Release of Blogger
- Publication of the FCC s Net Neutrality Rules Spawns a Flurry of Legal Challenges
- Freedom of Expression Under Attack in Mexico Social Network Users and Bloggers Face Violence, Political Backlash
- GPS Inventor Joins EFF in Fight Against Warrantless GPS Tracking
- California's Reader Privacy Act Signed into Law

---

S'abonner au fil RSS global de la revue de presse

---